list of comments
| From: | |
|---|---|
| Date: | Tue Apr 27 06:53:01 2010 |
| URL: | http://www.chameleongroup.org.uk/software/piano.html |
| Message: | |
| From: | |
| Date: | Sun Nov 15 07:52:27 2009 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | Correction:- g flat could be g flat or f |
| From: | hofmann-engl@chameleongroup.org.uk |
| Date: | Sun Nov 15 07:32:28 2009 |
| URL: | http://www.chameleongroup.org.uk/software/piano.html |
| Message: | Hi Bob Based on 'c' and measured against equal temperament (the common tuning of pianos), we get the 7th partial to be b flat (-31 cent), the 11th g flat (-49 cent), the 13th to be a flat (+ 41 cent) and the 14th just like the 7th to be b flat (- 31 cent). A deviation of 31 cent is already so high that we are stretching the boundaries of categorical perception. Still, considering that a bass note 'c' on the piano will induce resonance of the b flat 2 octaves above might indicated that we can accept the b flat to be part of a virtual pitch model. However, the 11th and 13th partials are so ambivalent that categorical perception can no longer apply. This is, the 11th partial might be perceived as g or g flat and the 13th as a flat or a. This is the reason why this virtual pitch model includes the 2nd, 5th, 6th, 7th and 15th partial only. However, I am not sure whether this answers your question. Please, feel free to continue this thread or email me if you prefer to do so. Best wishes Ludger |
| From: | robert.ehle@unco.edu |
| Date: | Sun Nov 15 02:59:51 2009 |
| URL: | http://www.chameleongroup.org.uk/software/piano.html |
| Message: | Hi, On the piano we have progressively higher inharmonic partials. It is my impression that this makes the 7th, 11th, 13th and 14th partials more consonant and probably allows them to support virtual pitch better than the true harmonics would. It brings the partials closer to equal tempered notes. Thus, piano composers like Ravel and Stravinsky might show preference for these intervals as do many jazz pianists. Any observations on this topic? Bob Ehle - UNC Greeley, CO |
| From: | webmaster@chameleongroup.org.uk |
| Date: | Thu May 7 18:41:10 2009 |
| URL: | http://www.chameleongroup.org.uk |
| Message: | Any further discussion between Dr Namhoff and Dr Hofmann- Engl will be deleted. |
| From: | Ludger |
| Date: | Thu May 7 15:30:59 2009 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | Sir: Not that it matters much as such, but it would not do any harm for you to use correct English for your ad homine attacks. You still have not been able to give a single example of any errors I have made and this after me asking you to furnish us with at least one example of such an error. Thanks for offering me your prayers. I hope you don't mind if I decline this offer. Regards Ludger |
| From: | Dr Namhoff |
| Date: | Thu May 7 09:44:48 2009 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | i have looked into your past and the only qualifications you have is in music and music preception, the ONLY advise you should be givin out on your website is to seek qualified professional help, its obvious you have npd and so could offer personal veiws and accounts, but npd is different in all cases, your comments are there as anger against previous relationships and frustrations that i guess you can not form a good relationship with anyone (yes its that plain to see), and i suggest you get some proffesional help, i pray for you. |
| From: | Ludger |
| Date: | Tue Apr 7 16:12:23 2009 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | Sorry, that you feel that way. You are very welcome to enlighten me about my errors. Regards Ludger |
| From: | Dr namhoff |
| Date: | Tue Apr 7 14:49:13 2009 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | your info on npd and so called help! is offensive to us professionals, this only shows you have npd and i suggest you get some help, |
| From: | Chameleon Group |
| Date: | Sat Jul 28 09:10:46 2007 |
| URL: | http://www.chameleongroup.org.uk |
| Message: | Wishing you all the best success in your search! Chameleongroup |
| From: | jenny giles |
| Date: | Fri Jul 27 23:18:44 2007 |
| URL: | http:// |
| Message: | just came across this site while researching my family tree. my Giles(surname )married an Easterbrook, none are common names, which is why i was brought to this site. Back to my research regards jenny |